The two medical paradigms of wellness and illness were being fought out in the 19th century the same time AT Still was developing Osteopathy. Although the illness paradigm (Louis Pasteur's Germ Theory) "won", the principle of wellness (Antoine Béchamp's Cellular Theory) was never disproven, and is far more resonant with modern understanding of ecology. In fact, we have recently discovered that the gut operates like a rainforest ecology, with some 10,000 species and subspecies of bacteria, without which we would not survive more than a few hours. Because bacteria are smaller than human cells, we find that there is 10x as much bacterial DNA in a healthy human body as there is human DNA! Although this debate was originally about disease, the principles apply equally well to physical aspects of the body such as skeletal structure.
Note that Cellular Theory (or Vitalism) does not deny that bacteria can bring illness, but rather, it says that most bacteria are either beneficial or harmless until the body becomes out of balance, and so the germ is no longer under the control of a healthy body ecology. In the vast majority of cases, an infection or "pulled muscle" or "slipped disc" is a sign that there was something wrong before the disease or discomfort even started. The aim of CST is to restore the basic conditions that encourage health so that the body then brings itself back into order. The principle of CST and many complementary therapy approaches is therefore no different from an ecological approach to the environment. If a stream is polluted or full of old shopping trolleys, or we make it difficult for one particular species of animal or plant to thrive, then nature will always find another balance. This is good, in that nature always wishes to make the most of what opportunities it has. However, at some point it will run out of adaptive capacity, or the balance it finds may not be particularly good for human life. If we try to think our way back out of this problem, it may be obvious (remove the pollution and trolleys), or something more subtle may be required to nudge the ecology back into a healthy balance.
As has been mentioned elsewhere, the debate between Pasteur and Béchamp was at its peak when Andrew Taylor Still was devising Osteopathy. This is a debate that continues to this day. As a complementary practitioner, my whole works revolves around the Cellular theory of Béchamp. Whereas mainstream medicine has largely chosen Pasteur's model, and this world view has been so popularised that it is take for granted as the only way to view life. Essentially, we have been taught to view life as a disease process rather than as a positive force.
There has never been any scientific disproof of Béchamp. In fact, many of the principles of Cellular theory are recognised in modern science (e.g. the way that bacteria and other unicellular organisms morph according to their environment). And the modern study of Ecology would very much agree with the tenets of Cellular theory when applied to a natural ecosystem. Why should the human body be any different?
The table below gives a comparison between these two very different approaches. In effect, Germ theory (the study of pathology and impersonal illness) is a subset of Cellular theory (the study of individual wellness), which applies when the ecology is seriously out of balance.
|GERM THEORY (PASTEUR))|
|Disease arises from micro-organisms outside the body.|
|Micro-organisms are generally to be guarded against.|
|The function of micro-organisms is constant.|
|The shapes and colours of micro-organisms are constant.|
|Every disease is associated with a particular micro-organism.|
|Micro-organisms are primary causal agents and are "bad".|
|Disease can "strike" anybody.|
|To prevent disease we have to "build defences" and kill the bad bacteria|
|Health is defined as an absence of illness|
|Mind over matter (includes "no pain, no gain")|
|We have to force the body to straighten out/loosen/soften|
|The Brain is the master and most important part Each part of the body has an innate intelligence.|
|CELLULAR THEORY (BÉCHAMP)|
|Disease arises from micro-organisms which in most cases already exist within the cells of the body.|
|These intracellular micro-organisms normally function to build and assist in the metabolic processes of the body.|
|The function of these organisms changes to assist in the catabolic (disintegration) processes of the host organism when that organism dies or is injured, which may be chemical as well as mechanical.|
|Micro-organisms change their shapes and colours to reflect the medium, and metamorphose according to their environment.|
|Every disease is associated with a particular condition and loss of internal ecological balance.|
|Micro-organisms become "pathogenic" as the ecological health of the host organism deteriorates. Hence, the condition of the host organism is the primary causal agent.|
|Disease is built by unhealthy pre-existing conditions. Therefore, some people are less susceptible because their lifestyle cultivates a healthy internal ecology. And some people are more susceptible - there are many possible reasons for this including mental state, pollutants, diet, conditions of gestation (before birth), etc.|
|To prevent disease we have to create and nurture conditions that predispose health and particularly conditions which increase the healthy adaptive capacity of the organism and the person.|
|Health is defined as a dynamic optimisation of energy expenditure vs response to the internal and external environment|
|Mind and body work cooperatively, each according to their appropriate strengths. The body speaks its own language|
|The body will straighten and loosen itself given the right information reaches the tissues.|
|Although the conscious will should be in charge, the body works best if the conscious minds relationship with it is one of a loved and valued lifetime companion|